1-888-440-9787
FREE Shipping on orders $199+
FREE Gifts with orders $100+
Current Buyback Products
How The Program Works
Buy a Qualifying
Buyback Product
Pull an Eligible
MVP Card
Trade Them In
For Store Credit
Authorized Mail-In Partner
Dave & Adam's is proud to be an authorized mail-in vendor for the MVP Buyback Program – meaning collectors from anywhere in the country can mail in their MVP cards directly to us and receive credit. Mail eligible cards to:
Dave & Adam's
Attn: Andrea Sherman
375 Commerce Dr
Amherst, NY 14228
Once we receive and verify your cards, we'll issue your store credit
straight to your Dave & Adam's account.
FAQ
When will the buyback program start and end?
All buyback programs are around a MVP winner or Championship Match winner. When the players have been picked, the buyback will start & an end date will be announced.
What will I receive in exchange for my cards? Can I get cash?
When you bring your cards into your hobby shop, you will receive store credit in exchange – not cash. The amount of store credit is determined by the pricing table for each product.
How do I determine the buyback value of my numbered cards?
It’s very simple. All MVP cards that are numbered greater than /100 will fetch $100 in credit. All numbered cards less than /100 will fetch $200 in credit. Thus, for /399, /350, /299, /275, /250, /199, /150, or /125 cards, the buyback offer is $100. For /99, /75, /50, /25, /5, /-5, or /1 cards, the buyback offer is $200. In the event of a back-to-back MVP or back-to-back-to-back MVP, 2024 Topps Chrome Baseball MVP stamped and reinserted numbered cards will have the following values: back-to-back MVP /199 is $400; /150 is $600; /99 is $800; /50 is $1,000; back-to-back-to-back MVP /199 is $600; /150 is $800; /99 is $1000; /50 is $1,200;
Can I redeem my cards if I don’t live near a participating hobby shop?
Yes, you can. Dave & Adam's has partnered with Topps to accept mailed-in eligible MVP Buyback cards for in-store or online credit.
Do the cards have to be in mint condition?
Cards do not need to be in mint condition. Ripped or altered cards will not be accepted for the buyback program, but as long as your card is in one piece, it will be eligible.